Opinion: Shearer vs. Cunliffe – how the numbers stack up
Monday 19 Nov 2012 10:55 a.m.
Cunliffe has 11 MPs in Labour who support him. He needs 13 to force a leadership vote.
Opinion by Political Reporter Patrick Gower
Camp Shearer is now claiming it is in the ascendancy in the battle for the Labour leadership.
Camp Cunliffe appears to be weakening.
At the weekend my colleague Brook Sabin and I approached every Labour MP to find out their position - and this is how the numbers stack up.
Now remember it is all about a February vote set down in Labour's constitution, where if 40 percent of the MPs - that's 14 - refuse to endorse David Shearer, then a leadership contest is triggered.
That contest would be under new rules and the entire party - grassroots members and unions - would get a say, rather than just MPs as it is now.
So the math is simple - if Cunliffe can get a total of 14 MPs (including himself of course) to refuse to endorse Shearer - he forces a leadership contest.
Shearer meanwhile needs to get 21 MPs (including himself) to see off a leadership contest.
Refusing to endorse Shearer: Camp Cunliffe potentials
- David Cunliffe
- Nanaia Mahuta
- Charles Chauvel
- Lianne Dalziel
- Sua William Sio
- Sue Moroney
- Moana Mackey
- Louisa Wall
- Rajen Prasad
- Parekura Horomira
- Rino Tirikatene
- Raymond Huo
- Total: 12
Cunliffe needs 14 to get to the 40 percent mark to trigger a leadership contest. There are 12 on this list but remember while some are tight Cunliffe, others will go with the tide.
Refusing to say: Position ‘ambiguous’
- Shane Jones
- Ross Robertson
- Total: 2
Shane Jones has not returned calls while Ross Robertson gave an ambiguous answer. Remember that Jones was suspended by Shearer over the Bill Liu affair. The votes of these two are crucial in the final result.
Camp Shearer: Standing by the leader
- David Shearer
- Grant Robertson
- David Parker
- Jacinda Ardern
- Maryan Street
- Clayton Cosgrove
- Phil Twyford - Refuses to say - believed to be Shearer
- Ruth Dyson - Refuses to say - believed to be Shearer
- Trevor Mallard
- Kris Faafoi
- Iain Lees-Galloway
- Damien O'Connor
- Darien Fenton
- Clare Curran
- Phil Goff
- Chris Hipkins
- Annette King - Refuses to say - believed to be Shearer
- David Clark
- Andrew Little
- Megan Woods
- Total: 20
Shearer needs to get to 21 (over 60 percent) to see off the challenge. Most of these have openly declared and Camp Shearer is saying they actually have 23 - and that means it is over for Cunliffe.
So there you have it. That's how the numbers stack up as of now.
MPs who want to change camps on this list are welcome to contact the 3 News political office.