Auckland mayoral hopeful John Tamihere wants landlords to promise not to increase rents, in exchange for a freeze on rates.
The controversial contender on Monday said he wouldn't raise rates in his first term, if elected in October.
"As a part of a general rates freeze over the next three years, I will ask landlords in Auckland to show goodwill by freezing rents for the next three years also," the former Labour Party MP said.
"Like all Aucklanders, landlords will not be paying increased rates, there are currently unprecedented low interest rates, and a capital gains tax is off the table. There has never been a better time for landlords to show their support for a rents freeze.
"My call to all landlords is a collective call to action that we all need a three-year breathing space to fix a number of broken things, so we can future-proof our city... I'm sure landlords will reflect deeply on their conscience because at least one leader has the backbone to ask them to step up."
- Phil Goff accuses John Tamihere of spreading 'fake news'
- Phil Goff vs John Tamihere: Clashing visions for the future
But Mayor Phil Goff says rather than giving the city a breather to fix things, it'll suck the council's coffers dry, calling the idea "incoherent and lacking in basic financial understanding".
"Tamihere has already promised a rise in water rates of $200-$300 for every household, which equals to a 12 percent increase in average general rates. So, to suggest a 3.5 percent rates cut is to take much more with one hand and give a little bit with the other," the incumbent - also a former Labour MP - said.
Goff has proposed a maximum 3.5 percent-a-year rates increase, up from the 2.5 percent increases he delivered in his first term.
"Under [Tamihere's] plan, the city would lose out on $3.8 billion dollars' worth of rates revenue on top of the $4.3 billion lost from the regional fuel tax. Where is the money going to come from to pay for the work that we desperately need to do in Auckland like transport and housing infrastructure?"
Tamihere has also proposed canning the 11.5c litre (including GST) regional fuel tax, intended to help cover the costs of improving the city's transport infrastructure.
"The reason we have had to invest $28 billion in infrastructure spend in the current 10-year budget is because year after year, Auckland has underinvested in crucial infrastructure," said Goff. "Tamihere is making the same mistake."
Tamihere has also promised a new two-storey harbour bridge, which Goff estimated would cost more than $10 billion.
"Tamihere's policies now cost more than $12 billion dollars while he is promising to cut revenue is $8 billion. These sorts of promises are fundamentally reckless, dishonest and unbelievable."
Tamihere reckons he can fund it all by cutting "waste".
"There are a number of bureaucrats and contractors on the council payroll who are paid extraordinary amounts of ratepayers' money," he said.
In the last financial year, Auckland Council reported spending less than $1 billion on its staff.
The election is on October 12.